About the song
“I Can’t Tell You Why” is one of the softer, more soulful tracks recorded by the Eagles, offering a distinct contrast to their more rock-driven anthems. Released in 1979, this song appeared on the album “The Long Run,” marking the first time that bassist Timothy B. Schmit, who had recently joined the band, took the lead vocals. This track showcases the Eagles’ versatility in blending rock with elements of R&B, creating a smooth, melodic sound that appealed to a broad audience.
The song was co-written by Timothy B. Schmit, Glenn Frey, and Don Henley, highlighting the collaborative spirit of the band even as they neared the end of their initial run together before disbanding in 1980 (they would later reunite in 1994). “I Can’t Tell You Why” features Schmit’s tender vocal delivery, underscored by a soft, flowing guitar and synthesizer arrangement, complemented by the restrained yet effective use of the electric guitar. The lyrics speak to the complexities of love and relationships, encapsulating the pain and confusion of being unable to reconcile or move forward, yet being unable to let go.
Upon its release, “I Can’t Tell You Why” quickly became a favorite among fans and reached a commendable position on the Billboard Hot 100, peaking at number 8. Its success contributed to the overall achievement of “The Long Run” album, which itself was a commercial success, despite being critically viewed as falling short of the expectations set by their previous works, such as “Hotel California.”
For those with a seasoned ear and an appreciation for the softer side of classic rock, “I Can’t Tell You Why” represents the Eagles’ ability to cross genre boundaries and appeal to fans of both rock and R&B. The song has endured as a staple on classic rock and easy listening stations, retaining its appeal through its beautifully crafted melody, heartfelt lyrics, and smooth vocal performance. It stands out as a poignant reminder of the Eagles’ musical range and their skill in capturing the emotional nuances of personal relationships in their songs.
Châu