About the song
“Oh! Carol,” a catchy and energetic doo-wop tune, burst onto the international music scene in 1958, leaving a lasting mark on pop culture. Written by a young Neil Sedaka alongside Howard Greenfield, the song quickly rose to fame, captivating audiences with its infectious melody and playful lyrics. However, the story behind “Oh! Carol” goes beyond catchy hooks and teenage romance.
The song holds a special significance for Sedaka. “Carol” is a direct reference to Carol Klein, his ex-girlfriend from high school and a fellow songwriter at the legendary Brill Building in New York City. This shared history adds a layer of bittersweet nostalgia to the song, which chronicles a young man’s yearning for a lost love.
But “Oh! Carol” didn’t end there. Interestingly, the song sparked a playful musical exchange. Carol Klein, who had by then married songwriter Gerry Goffin, took the melody of “Oh! Carol” and penned a cheeky response titled “Oh! Neil.” Released under the stage name Carole King, the song playfully addressed Sedaka’s pining lyrics. While “Oh! Neil” wasn’t a commercial success, it stands as a delightful example of musical camaraderie and a little friendly one-upmanship between former flames.
“Oh! Carol” wasn’t just a hit in the United States. It transcended national boundaries, reaching the Top 10 on the Billboard Hot 100 and achieving even higher chart positions in the UK and the Netherlands. The song’s success solidified Neil Sedaka’s burgeoning career and established him as a rising star.
Beyond its chart success, “Oh! Carol” is remembered for its innovative incorporation of a spoken word verse. Sedaka’s distinctive delivery adds a layer of dramatic flair and personal connection to the song. This innovative technique helped pave the way for future artists to experiment with spoken word elements in pop music.
The B-side of the “Oh! Carol” single, “One Way Ticket,” also proved to be a success story, reaching the No. 1 spot in Japan. This double-sided hit solidified Sedaka’s international appeal and showcased his songwriting versatility.
Although released decades ago, “Oh! Carol” continues to resonate with listeners today. Its timeless melody, playful lyrics, and innovative structure have ensured its place in pop music history. The song’s backstory, with its connection to Carole King and the “Oh! Neil” response, adds a layer of intrigue and human connection that further endears it to fans.
Video
Lyrics
Oh! Carol, I am but a fool
Darling, I love you, though you treat me cruel
You hurt me and you make me cry
But if you leave me, I will surely die
Darling, there will never be another
Cause I love you so
Don’t ever leave me, say you’ll never go
I will always want you for my sweetheart
No matter what you do
Oh! Carol, I’m so in love with you
Oh! Carol, I am but a fool
Darling, I love you, though you treat me cruel
You hurt me and you make me cry
But if you leave me, I will surely die
Darling, there will never be another
Cause I love you so
Don’t ever leave me, say you’ll never go
I will always want you for my sweetheart
No matter what you do
Oh! Carol, I’m so in love with you